Why Lens Coatings Are So Important in Photography

In recent years, some lens designers have updated their lenses with new lens coatings. For instance, Pentax’s newest limited lenses feature an existing optical design with only a few improvements, including a better lens coating.

When testing such lenses, reviewers generally agree that new lens coatings significantly improve the image quality (especially contrast and flare), but never quite explain how lens coatings work. That is the aim of this article.

A collection of lenses with anti-reflection coatings. Photo by Mengliu Di.

The Origins of Lens Coatings

Historically, coatings have been introduced to reduce light loss in optical systems. Indeed, each time the light passes from an optical medium to another, a fraction of the energy is lost because of a reflection phenomenon. This phenomenon of reflection occurs naturally on any type of surface between two materials, be it the surface of a river, a glass, or a mirror. The only difference is the amount of light reflected. For glass, it is commonly accepted that 96% of the light is transmitted and 4% is reflected.

The equation behind these numbers is:

R is the reflected energy, n1 the refractive index of the first medium (1.0 for air) and n2 the refractive index of the second medium (glass, in our case). Glass refractive index is usually in the 1.4 to 1.8 range. The 4% value derives from a typical 1.5 refractive index.

This lost energy may seem minor at first. However, it accumulates for each lens surface inside a given lens system. A prime lens typically contains 7 to 12 elements (which means about 15-20 lens surfaces, since each lens element has both an air/glass and a glass/air interface) whereas a modern zoom lens design features more than 20 elements (which means roughly 40 lens surfaces).

This typical prime lens would only let half of the light go through, whereas the zoom lens would transmit less than 20% of the light incoming.

A diagram of the optics within a Canon EF 24-105mm f/4 IS USM lens. Illustration by Alessio Facchin and licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

The first lens coating can be traced back to the English mathematician and scientist Lord Rayleigh (John William Strutt, 3rd Baron Rayleigh). Much to his surprise, he discovered in 1886 that old tarnished glass transmits more light than new untarnished glass. Lord Rayleigh discovered that two successive interfaces air/tarnish and tarnish/glass transmit more light than a single air/glass interface. Several patents followed this discovery and lens coating gradually improved.

Lord Rayleigh made a groundbreaking discovery about light transmission through glass in 1886.

For photographers, a major improvement occurred in the 1930s. In 1935, Zeiss engineer Alexander Smakula patented the first coating using multiple layers of chemicals. This design, as we will explain later, dramatically improved the performance of lens coatings and led to unprecedented levels of optical performance.

Light transmission at the interface between air and glass, without (left) and with (right) coatings.

How Effective Are Lens Coatings at Improving Light Transmission?

A lens coating typically brings the transmission from about 96% to above 99.7%. This means that a typical prime lens can now transmit 95% of the light (up from 50%) and our zoom can transmit 88% (up from 20%).

Obviously, lens coating brings a great improvement to low-light photography. The improvement is all the more striking as the number of optical lenses used in photographic lenses tends to increase in modern designs. If in the early days of photography, it was common to use a lens doublet, it is nowadays common to exceed 15 lens elements in computer-designed lenses. Consequently, light transmission is an increasingly important matter for lens designers.

The Problems of Low Contrast and Lens Flares

There are other advantages to the use of coating on lenses. The energy that is not transmitted is reflected back and forth several times in the lens and ends up being added to the final image. At best, dark areas are illuminated by diffuse light, which results in lower dynamic range and contrast. At worst, a powerful light source from the scene also produces bright spots inside the image, known as flares.

In 2016, the lens manufacturer Zeiss conducted an interesting experiment to demonstrate the importance of lens coatings. The manufacturer produced two copies of the exact same lens, a 21mm f/2.8 Distagon, one with optical coatings and the other without.

An uncoated Zeiss Distagon 21mm f2.8 ZE lens (left) and a T*-coated one (right). Photo by Andreas BogenschĂĽtz and via Zeiss.

Below are some of the images obtained by both lenses in the same condition. Overall, the image quality is drastically reduced for all the pictures taken with the lens without coatings.

Photos captured with (above) and without (below) lens coatings. Photos by Zeiss.
Photos captured with (above) and without (below) lens coatings. Photos by Zeiss.

The Physics of Lens Coating Designs

The design of a coating can be based on various physical principles. The list includes index-based methods, GRIN materials, polarization, diffraction theory, and even metamaterials…

The simplest form of anti-reflective coating, historically, brings us back to the transmission equation. It appears that the total transmission can be improved by adding a medium with a lower refractive index (for instance, 1.3) than the one of glass (for instance, 1.5).

With the simple coating proposed above, one can improve the light transmission from 96% to 97.8%. However, this type of single-layer coating is still far from 0% reflection.

To improve the coating performance, lens designers tend to use diffraction theory instead. Using the wave nature of light, one can choose a thin layer of material to cancel perfectly the reflection. A layer with a thickness of 1/4 the wavelength means that the wave reflected on the glass will travel an extra 1/2 wavelength (1/4 wavelength coming in, and 1/4 wavelength coming out) compared to the wave reflected on the AR-coating. Thus, the two waves are shifted with opposite phases and their sum is null.

Art view of the diffraction theory introduced with a wavelength/4 coating. The ray reflected from the glass and the ray reflected from the coating cancel each other.

There are a couple of caveats to this ideal case. Firstly, light usually comes in a spectrum instead of a single wavelength (a single wavelength does not really exist in nature, you can find some in man-made laser sources). For visible light, wavelengths are ranging from 400nm (blue light) to 800nm (red light). This means that the thickness required to eliminate reflections varies significantly with the color. It might also mean that all colors are not transmitted equally, which really means that the lens coating will introduce a color cast.

Secondly, our computation assumed that the light rays are perpendicular to the glass surface. In practical cases, however, they can fall on the lens at a large angle. As soon as an angle is introduced, the optical path inside the anti-reflection coating increases which results in lower transmission.

In order to solve these issues, the best solution is to add several layers of coating. A common structure alternates 1/4 wavelength-coating with 1/2 wavelength-coating. It is common to have lenses with typically 7 layers of coating.

A multi-layer coating pattern.

How Are Lens Coatings Mass Produced?

The wavelength in visible light is around 500nm, and lens coatings are typically 100nm to 250nm thin layers. To put this into perspective, an average human hair is about a thousand times thicker.

The layer is also supposed to be uniform throughout the glass, so that layer thickness only varies by a few percent. This step cannot be performed until the glass is cut and polished to its final shape as the polishing process would otherwise remove the coating.

The modern industrial process uses vapor deposition technologies. It is typically done in a vacuum chamber with chemicals to evaporate.

Here is a short video of a machine designed for this purpose:

You can see on the top part of the system a set of lenses ready for coating. These lenses will be rotated through the coating process in order to even the layer of anti-reflection coating.

Conclusion

The science of lens coatings is almost century-old. Yet, the topic is still actively being researched. The much-discussed meta-material technologies making headlines these days could bring possible improvements over existing lens coatings.

Given the increasing complexity of lens designs, any progress in lens coating is for the best as it also improves light transmission and image contrast.


About the author: Timothee Cognard is an optical expert and photographer based in Paris, France.


Image credits: Header photo from Depositphotos

Discussion