TIME Rape Victim Cover Photo Slammed as ‘Exploitative’
TIME’s latest international issue features a portrait of a rape victim of the civil war in South Sudan. The magazine’s choice of photo is sparking an outcry online, with people calling the cover “exploitative.”
The cover photo is for a story titled: “The Secret War Crime: Ending the source of conflict rape.”
After it was shared with the world a week ago, the cover immediately received backlash over the way Ayak was portrayed. Here’s a sampling of some of the most popular critical Tweets:
Hi, @TIME. I have so many questions about this wildly exploitative cover. pic.twitter.com/2Ysjj4nu9C
— Zoé S. (@ztsamudzi) March 12, 2016
[CN: rape, sexual violence]
So if Ayak is a rape survivor and vulnerable, why is she nearly naked on the cover of your magazine? @TIME— Zoé S. (@ztsamudzi) March 12, 2016
[CN: genocide]
Would you have put a naked Bosnian woman on your cover to discuss systematic rape during the genocide or is that distasteful?— Zoé S. (@ztsamudzi) March 12, 2016
That makes 2 of us @TIME. A rape survivor made vulnerable on the cover of an int'l magazine is wrong in so many ways https://t.co/0Yh2q1m0gI
— Fatima Syed (@fatimasyed401) March 13, 2016
A comparison of two TIME covers on rape. @ReadingThePix @johnedwinmason pic.twitter.com/dGeJ0SCGs0
— ninaberman (@ninaberman) March 14, 2016
Others, including Nat Geo’s Deputy Director of Photography Patrick Witty, came to TIME and Addario’s defense:
Hell of a cover by @lynseyaddario @TIME @bryanrwalsh…Ending the scourge of wartime rape by @arynebaker pic.twitter.com/GVetx6I93V
— Patrick Witty (@patrickwitty) March 10, 2016
@patrickwitty Agreed. Very powerful cover photo. And a very horrible reality for far too many women and girls.
— Imani Crawford (@ImaniCrawford) March 11, 2016
Amazing cover on Time Magazine. Cudos to the editorial team. @TIME pic.twitter.com/b6c1X1W2Jv
— Claire Lewis (@clairerowanlewi) March 17, 2016
@ztsamudzi @TIME I find it beautiful, tragic, vulnerable, courageous, unbroken, timeless.
— TenneyNaumer (@TenneyNaumer) March 13, 2016
In a separate article on TIME, Addario shared the story of how the photo came about, saying that war rape is “always an extremely difficult and sensitive story to cover.”
“Once I went over the guidelines with Ayak – in terms of how she felt about being photographed, given that her image would be seen by thousands around the world – I spent several hours with her,” Addario says. “We sat down with Ayak, and discussed my vision for her portrait, and she didn’t hesitate at all; she understood what I was trying to convey, and as I photographed, I showed her the images on my camera to ensure she understood what I was capturing.”
“It seemed that the very act of photographing Ayak and her unborn child gave her the opportunity to celebrate the very thing her perpetrators had tried to rob from her – her beauty and her dignity.”